Dear Sylvain, We have looked into the issue with the 2MASS id problems you kindly pointed out in the electronic version of our paper 2013AJ....146..133M. The 2MASS ids of the Pleiades stars you listed are indeed wrong. We would like to kindly ask you to replace the bad ids with the good ones at your earliest convenience. I would like to thank you for finding this error in our table. Best regards, Szabolcs On 2/25/2015 11:39, Szabolcs Meszaros wrote: > Dear Sylvain, Carlos, > > This is indeed interesting, thank you for checking the accuracy of our > table. I am looking into what might have happened, and I will get back > to you when I know more. > > Cheers, > Szabolcs > > On 2/25/2015 1:13, Carlos Allende wrote: >> >> Hi Szabolcs, >> >> Apparently there is an error with the 2MASS IDs for a few of the >> stars in our 2013 paper. Can you check on this issue? >> >> Best, >> Carlos >> >> -------- Forwarded Message -------- >> Subject: 2MASS IDs in 2013AJ....146..133M >> Date: Tue, 24 Feb 2015 18:55:15 +0100 >> From: GUEHENNEUX Sylvain (OBS) >> To: callende@iac.es >> CC: pierre.ocvirk@astro.unistra.fr >> >> >> >> Dear Dr. Allende Prieto, >> >> I contact you about a possible problem with one table in the AJ paper >> 2013AJ....146..133M. I tried to join the first author (Dr. Meszaros) but >> I failed. I hope you can help me to solve the problem with the table. >> In the electronic version of 2013AJ....146..133M, all 2MASS IDs in the >> table 4 are in the 2MASS catalog (cat. II/246 in VizieR database; >> http://vizier.u-strasbg.fr/viz-bin/VizieR-3?-source=II/246), except for >> 54 objects belonging to the Pleiades. >> These 54 2MASS IDs are possible mistakes. For example, 2MASS >> J03403073+2429143 would be a mistake for 2MASS J03403072+2429143. Please >> find enclosed the 54 possible mistakes we find at CDS followed by the >> probable correct 2MASS names we propose. >> >> Can you confirm to us that the 54 2MASS IDs are or are not mistakes? And >> in case they are, do you authorize us to replace them by the 2MASS IDs >> proposed in the enclosed file? >> >> Best regards, >> >> Sylvain Guehenneux